Boy Scouts of Babylon Mega-Round-Up, February 17, 2013

Scout's Honor: Sexual Abuse in America's Most Trusted Institution by Patrick Boyle

Michael Agrippine • Jason Asthana • William Brewer • Stanley Brown • William Butcher • Stephen Corcoran • Matthew Cross • Jason Freeman • Vance Hein • Scott Herrick • Glenn Jordan • Glen Matteson • James Mobley • Edward Orenchuk III • Stephen Perry • Brian David Robbins • David Watkins

In “honor” of the Boy Scouts of America wimping out on the decision of whether or not to allow gay adults to work as scoutmasters and in other volunteer positions (no, the weaselly non-decision to allow local units to decide if they want to continue to discriminate on a whim is not good enough), and in response to the professional homophobes attempting to muster hysteria about the Boy Scouts becoming a den of pedophiles if gay men are allowed to serve (the BSA is a den of pedophiles and always has been, without any involvement by openly gay adults), we hereby present this extra-long rundown of perverts and alleged perverts to emerge from the ranks of the BSA… recently, that is. (Of course, we’ve been following the BSA’s perv epidemic for some time… And just wait until we start reviewing the names we’re only now finding in the BSA’s own Perversion Files.)

Michael AgrippineCharged: Michael James Agrippine, 47, substitute teacher, Union Terrace Elementary School, Allentown, Pennsylvania; former full-time teacher, Allentown Central Catholic High School; Eagle Scout and Cub Scout volunteer; husband and father of two girls; with felony institutional sexual assault, felony aggravated indecent assault, felony indecent assault, and misemeanor indecent assault, allegedly committed against a nine-year-old male special-education student. reports: “Agrippine was in the boys’ [school] restroom … when the victim was escorted there by a female teacher, authorities said. The woman did not enter the restroom and Agrippine approached the boy, held him against a wall and assaulted him, according to authorities. Agrippine denied the allegations at his preliminary arraignment … but court records say he admitted to the alleged assault.” Agrippine is currently free on $75,000 bail. Story:, January 23, 2013; Morning Call, January 23, 2013; WFMZ, January 23, 2013; Morning Call, January 24, 2013

Jason AsthanaSentenced: Jason Alun Asthana, 32, Beaver Scout leader, Billingshurst, West Sussex, U.K., to four years and eight months following his December conviction of sexually assaulting a boy under the age of 13, and a guilty plea to “making 20 indecent images of children,” according to This is Sussex. Story: Daily Mail, December 17, 2012; This is Sussex, February 3, 2013

William BrewerIndicted: William Todd Brewer, 42, former Boy Scouts executive / head of the Northwest Mississippi District of the Chickasaw Council, who “oversaw Scouts in DeSoto, Panola, Tate and Tunica counties,” according to the Commercial Appeal, on 23 charges — 10 counts of possession of child pornography, eight counts of sexual battery, and five counts of fondling — involving five boys under the age of 16. No trial date has been set. The Appeal notes that Brewer, in custody since his arrest in July, 2012, previously worked for the equally homophobic Salvation Army for 18 years. Story: Commercial Appeal, July 10, 2012; WAFB, February 12, 2013; Commercial Appeal, February 13, 2013

Stanley Mark BrownNew charges: Stanley Mark Brown, 64, of Oshawa, Ontario; president, Whitby Warriors lacrosse club; inductee, Whitby Sports Hall of Fame; skate shop owner; and former volunteer leader, 20th Boy Scouts Troop; who was first arrested in August, 2012, and charged with five counts each of gross indecency and indecent assault and two counts of sexual assault, after several men accused him of sexually molesting them during the 1970s and 80s. Brown was arrested again January 25, 2013, on new charges: three counts of gross indecency, three counts of indecent assault and one count of possession of an unlicensed firearm. Story:, August 15, 2012;, January 26, 2013

William Leonard ButcherCharged: William Leonard Butcher, 19, of Provo, Utah, with “16 counts of first-degree felony aggravated sexual abuse of a child, seven counts of second-degree felony forcible sexual abuse and one count of first-degree felony sodomy on a child,” involving a total of 15 alleged victims, according to the Salt Lake Tribune, including “a 14-year-old boy when [Butcher] was 17 at a Boy Scout camp in Arizona — though he cannot be charged in Utah for that alleged abuse.” Butcher reportedly “walked into the Provo Police Department and told officers he had abused 12 people, according to charging documents. Investigators say Butcher told them the victims ranged from infants to a 19-year-old man. And while Butcher claimed he had abused his first victim when he was 14, most of it happened when he was an adult, and as recently as last month, according to charges.” Story: Salt Lake Tribune, February 14, 2013

Stephen CorcoranSued: Boy Scouts of America Patriots’ Path Council, Florham Park, New Jersey, in the matter of Stephen Corcoran, 45, former assistant Scoutmaster, Boy Scout Troop 173, Morris Plains, New Jersey, who in January, 2012, was charged with possession and distribution of child pornography. Corcoran, who is not named in the civil suit, has pleaded not guilty; he was re-arrested in December on new charges of aggravated sexual assault and endangering the welfare of a child. Per, the lawsuit “details allegations of repeated abuse during the 1990s in a cabin at Camp Alpine in Bergen County, at a hotel room in Vermont and other places.” The suit also claims “that the boy endured ‘multiple weekly assaults’ between the ages of 15 and 16 and that the Scout leader ‘arranged a threesome’ with an older Scout and the boy.” Also named in the suit, but not a defendant, is Bruce Benson, Troop 173 committee chairman, who is accused of plying the same boy with alcohol, but not accused of sexual abuse. Story: Conservative Babylon, February 7, 2012;, November 14, 2012;, December 21, 2012; CBS New York, December 21, 2012

United StatesCharged: Matthew Aaron Cross, 36, of Wasilla, Alaska, “whose wife said he was involved in Boy Scouts and providing day care at his church,” reports the Mat-Su Valley Frontiersman, with one count of second-degree sexual abuse of a ten-year-old boy and domestic violence, according to an Alaska State Troopers press release. The Frontiersman also reports that investigator Toma Caldarea wrote in an affidavit that he “talked to the boy’s brother, who said he’d seen Cross kissing a boy ‘like a man kisses his wife.’” Cross, currently free on $50,000 bail, reportedly “admitted to touching the boy’s ‘privates,” and attempted to excuse his actions in a rambling statement as “being like an expression of love.” Story: Alaska State Troopers, January 16, 2013; Mat-Su Valley Frontiersman, January 19, 2013

Jason Wayne FreemanArrested: Jason Wayne Freeman, 39, former assistant Scoutmaster, Boy Scout Troop 444, Menifee, California, and former volunteer, Menifee Youth Foundation; on suspicion of committing lewd acts with a child, sexual penetration by force, and first-degree residential burglary, after a man discovered an intruder, alleged to be Freeman, in bed with his daughter. Upon discovery, according to the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department, the suspect jumped out a bedroom window and fled. Story: Riverside County Sheriff’s Department (booking info); San Diego Union-Tribune, December 12, 2012; San Diego Union-Tribune, January 22, 2013; San Diego Union-Tribune, January 23, 2013

United StatesSued: Boy Scouts of America and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in the matter of Vance Paul Hein, 61, former scoutmaster and Mormon church youth leader, West Chester, Pennsylvania, “deemed a sexually violent predator by the state Sexual Offender’s Assessment Board, per, and who, explains AP, “is in prison for a parole violation related to his 1999 misdemeanor conviction” involving plaintiff Melvin Novak, when Novak was 14. Hein “originally got probation but is now serving 15 to 30 years for possessing child pornography,” according to Novak’s attorney, Stewart J. Eisenberg. “In his complaint,” reports the Los Angeles Times, “Novak alleges that pedophiles were involved in scouting for decades, as demonstrated when the Boy Scouts of America in October released confidential documents — known as the ‘perversion files‘ — that list 1,200 alleged abusers who were weeded out of the organization between 1959 and 1985. … Novak said he is suing the Mormon Church because it failed to conduct a background check before Hein was hired.” The scout troop is sponsored by the LDS Marshallton 2nd Ward. Story: Daily Local News, May 23, 2012;, August 17, 2012; Los Angeles Times, December 12, 2012; AP, December 13, 2012; Philadelphia Inquirer, December 14, 2012; Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, December 17, 2012

Scott Allan HerrickConviction, sentence upheld: Scott Allan Herrick, 41, former director, Gerber Boy Scouts Camp, Twin Lakes, Michigan; pool safety instructor for third-grade children, YMCA, Muskegon; and former U.S. Marine; on appeal of six counts of child pornography crimes, to which he was sentenced to 95 years. As recounted by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Michigan: “Herrick surreptitiously videotaped boys as they were dressing in the boys’ locker room in the YMCA in Muskegon and kept a massive collection of 100,000 images of child pornography with him at the Gerber Boy Scout Camp in Twin Lakes, Michigan. He was convicted at trial of three counts of attempting to produce child pornography. On the first day of trial, Herrick pleaded guilty to two counts of distributing child pornography and one count of possessing child pornography. The Honorable Paul L. Maloney, Chief U.S. District Judge, presided over the trial and sentencing. He considered Herrick’s assertion at sentencing that he had no sexual interest in children to be preposterous.” Story: U.S. Attorney’s Office, January 6, 2012; U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), January 6, 2012;, January 28, 2013

Glenn JordanSued: Boy Scouts of America, Mataguay Scout Ranch, San Diego, California, and Glenn Jordan, 47, former Boy Scout camp counselor and convicted sex offender who served seven years for a variety of crimes, including harmful matter sent with intent of seduction of minor; lewd or lascivious acts with a child 14 or 15 years of age and offender 10 or more years older than victim; sodomy with a minor under 18 years of age; oral copulation with a minor under 18 years of age; and sexual penetration with a foreign object of a victim under 18 years of age.

According to a press release from plaintiff’s attorneys Manly & Stewart: “The suit alleges that at age 14 to 15 the victim was sexually abused in a hot tub and other locations by Glenn Jordan , a camp counselor who was not properly supervised. … According to the complaint, after Plaintiff joined the Boy Scouts of America he attended Mataguay Scout Ranch every summer from 1998-2000. The Ranch operated one-week sleep-away camps throughout the summer where Defendant, Glenn Jordan , worked as a counselor. Glenn Jordan met and took an interest in Plaintiff in 1998 when Plaintiff was fourteen years old. Jordan brought Plaintiff over to his house and invited him into the hot tub where Jordan fondled the Plaintiff.

“The next occurrence took place at the same Ranch the following year when Plaintiff was fifteen years old, in either September or October 1999. During camp, Jordan sodomized Plaintiff five to ten times and orally copulated Plaintiff. Jordan made Plaintiff orally copulate him. Jordan made Plaintiff ejaculate on him. Jordan told Plaintiff that he loved him. Jordan made him get into the camp hot tub naked with other minors. At least a dozen instances of abuse are alleged. The abuse ended when Plaintiff reported it to the police and his parents.” Story: Manly & Stewart press release, January 16, 2013

Glen MattesonSentenced: Glen Matteson, 53, Boy Scout leader; assistant soccer coach, Chariho High School, Wood River Junction, Rhode Island, state prison employee, and married father of three sons; to five years in federal prison, ten years’ supervised release and sex-offender registration, following his November guilty plea to one count each of receipt, possession and distribution of child pornography, according to the Westerly Sun, which notes that Matteson “is still awaiting trial in state court on a charge of indecent solicitation of a child.” Matteson was arrested in February, 2012, after allegedly exchanging inappropriate text messages with a 16-year-old boy, whose parents contacted police. With the parents’ permission, an officer continued the cell-phone exchange with Matteson, which reportedly turned “sexual in nature.” Police say a search of Matteson’s home computer turned up images of child porn. Story: Conservative Babylon, April 15, 2012; Westerly Sun, February 15, 2013

James Donald MobleyCharged: James Donald Mobley, 46, fourth grade teacher, Tenino Elementary School, Tenino, Washington, private tutor and scoutmaster (2004-13), with receipt and possession of child pornography, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Washington, which reports: “According to records filed in the case, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service has been investigating an international company that distributed child pornography through the mails and via download to personal computers. In May 2011, foreign law enforcement executed a search of the business and seized hundreds of child pornography DVDs and business records. An analysis of those records revealed that on multiple occasions between February 2009 and January 2011, Mobley had purchased suspected child pornography from the company. In a search of Mobley’s home, law enforcement seized a computer hard drive and additional DVDs of child pornography.” Story: U.S. Attorney’s Office, January 17, 2013; KIRO, January 17, 2013

Edward Orenchuk IIICharged: Edward Orenchuk III, 23, Eagle Scout; assistant scoutmaster, Boy Scout Troop 243, Garden City, New York; and page, Garden City Public Library; with three counts of promoting a sexual performance by a child as a sexually motivated felony, and three counts of possessing a sexual performance by a child (i.e., possessing and promoting child pornography), according to the Nassau County District Attorney’s Office. D.A. Kathleen Rice stated that “during August and September 2012, Investigators from the DA’s Office observed Orenchuk making multiple images of child pornography available over the Internet for download by other people. Investigators tracked the source of those images to a Wheeler Avenue residence in Garden City. Orenchuk implicated himself during the execution of a search warrant at this home … indicating that he had hundreds of images on his personal computer.” Rice notes that the images “contain children as young as five years old.” and adds: “This defendant’s regular contact with children in a position of authority makes these charges that much more disturbing. My office is committed to aggressively investigating and prosecuting those who traffic in this horrific material.” Story: Nassau County District Attorney’s Office, December 12, 2012

Stephen PerryCharged: Stephen Perry, 27, “highly touted” Eagle Scout (Troop 132), Carmel, Indiana, and former Boy Scouts camp counselor, with conspiracy to commit murder. Perry is accused of offering a co-worker $15,000 and a “money machine” (for counterfeiting) to kill his estranged wife, in order to end the couple’s impending divorce case and free himself from her six-figure student-loan debt. Perry reportedly told the co-worker: “You’re black. I know y’all know people.” The co-worker recorded a phone call from Perry and took it straight to Perry’s wife, who contacted police. Perry’s trial is scheduled to begin in June. Story: WANE, January 31, 2013; AP, January 31, 2013; Indianapolis Star, January 31, 2013; Gawker, February 1, 2013

Brian David RobbinsArrested: Brian David Robbins, 30, scoutmaster, Parker, Colorado, on suspicion of sexual exploitation of a child, according to the Parker Police Department, which reports that a search of Robbins’s home turned up “numerous items of evidence … including digital images of unknown child victims.” Robbins is currently in custody on a $50,000 bond. Story: Parker Police Department, February 13, 2013

David Brian WatkinsPreliminary hearing waived: David Brian Watkins, 49, founder and former scoutmaster, Boy Scout Troop 1028, Keswick, Virginia, who was arrested in Novemeber, 2012, and charged with forcible sodomy allegedly committed against a boy in 2005. Police believe there may be other victims. The Hook reports that during Watkins’s 2006 divorce, his then-wife accused him of pedophilia. Story: The Hook, November 28, 2012; The Hook, December 4, 2012; Daily Progress, January 7, 2013; NBC 29, January 21, 2013


Related posts (automatically generated):

  1. Boy Scouts of Babylon Round-Up, February 23, 2012
  2. Boy Scouts of Babylon Round-Up, February 7, 2012
  3. Boy Scouts of Babylon Round-Up, March 27, 2012
  4. Boy Scouts of Babylon Round-Up, March 7, 2012
  5. Black Collar Crime Round-Up: February 4, 2013
Filed under Boy Scouts of America, Catholics Gone Wild, Mormons Amok

Posted Sunday, February 17, 2013 | Permalink | Trackback

Comments are closed.